I heard back from Movietyme regarding the My Bloody Valentine disc I was sent...
Stephen:
We received "My Bloody Valentine" Blu-ray that you have there as new from one of our suppliers. We are very sorry that you received a used disc...we were completely unaware that it was used. We had to order that title from a supplier that we dont normally use, but they were the only company that had it in stock...all of our regular suppliers list it as out of print. We will not use this supplier again!! Since this title is not available anywhere else..we can only issue you a refund. Please ship it back to us, and we will credit you for the cost of the disc..and the cost of shipping.
All's well that ends well then.