View Single Post
  #315  
Old 5th July 2012, 11:30 AM
Splatterdragon73 Splatterdragon73 is offline
Cult Acolyte
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: From the bowels of Newcastle Upon Tyne he came....to collect DVDs and BRs!
Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by norliss View Post
Another title that seems to come off worse in a comparison with the BU release. Arrow's effort is noticably weaker than BU with a lower bitrate etc.
No doubt this is the reason a friend of mine was disappointed with Arrow's transfer and found subsequent satisfaction with BU's BR. He holds on to the former for the packaging and extras and keeps the latter for the PQ.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen@Cult Labs View Post
Yeah, half the bitrate of the BU version does it no favours.
Too true and another case of BU coming out on top in the PQ stakes.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steel76 View Post
Arrow really needs to boost the bitrate and better their encodings, as they always have problems with this compared to the BU discs.

Another thing Arrow must learn is to put ALL High Def extras on the second disc, which gives the movie much more room to breath in.
As the more High Def stuff you cram on a disc, even dual layer, the more the compression suffers.

I love Arrows packagings and extras, but the quality on the movie itself should ALWAYS be the top priority.
If they get better at the encodings, then they will REALLY leave BU in the dust.
Well said and the only extra suitable for inclusion on the film disc should be any potential audio commentary.
__________________
When the going gets tough the tough take the law into their own hands.
Reply With Quote