Quote:
Originally Posted by Demdike@Cult Labs  Why is Luke wallowing? He was okay at the end of ROTJ.
How was The Phantom Menace not coherent? It plays out perfectly well. It may not be to the Star Wars police liking - too much about trade relationships - but it sets up Palpatine's rise to power very nicely. Oh and Darth Maul is a fine villain.
Sure Jake LLoyd was shit as was Jar Jar but the duel of the fates was the best sequence bar none since the end of Jedi. |
Luke was ok at the end of ROTJ? How do you know? he was in it about 2 minutes and had no dialogue. That sounds like an assumption.
Phantom menace was dragged down by all that trade federation nonsense. Not to mention the awful ear stinging dialogue.